Time to bring out the sarcasm machine!
Well! This is certanly the most UN-biast place to post this question! REPCOMM FTW1010101010101 1337
In all seriousness, they are completely diferent genres, so it is unfair to compare them. I love them both for what their for. A shooter and an RPG.
BTW my friend just knifed his way through the better part of the first level.