I have decided to put this up to show what goes on against us in other forums. (Well not us, but mandalorians and Travis)
By a guy on the Jedi council forums:
DEAR KAREN TRAVISS,
While I have enjoyed the general storyline of your books, you need get something straight.
3 clone troopers, even if they are nulls, ARE NO MATCH FOR AN ARMED JEDI KNIGHT OF EVEN MEDIOCRE SKILL, EVEN IF SAID JEDI IS CORNERED! In the 501st book, you even had a Spartti clone as the hero in a 3 v 1 battle against a lone Jedi.
You have elevated the Mandos as "almost Jedi" but without the force, and that just isn't the case.
Also, I sometimes feel like there is too much conversation, like a high school student who is adding non-relevant data to meet a required word count.
So anyway, back off on the "Super Mando" stuff.
Posted under the topic, what do you think of the Republic commando Novels?:
I think these are the weakest books out there, along with the Clone Wars novelizations and a third of the Legacy of the Jedi series (Guess which third). Any thoughts?
It appears that if I mention the author of these books by name, I get banned, so lets just call her the author.
I hate these books. I think the author is, hands down, the worst Star Wars author ever. Her books are boring, she invents new Jedi powers left and right like she has never read another Star Wars book. And I am sick of her writing in a different language, forcing the reader to be constantly looking up words. Does anyone else feel this way? I'm sick of how she is now writing just about EVERY Star Wars book out there. Does she have some strange contract with Lucas Books, or does Lucas Books actually like the crap she writes? Thoughts?
Under the same topic
I hate the LotF as a whole even when there were good books in the series. It's the overall thing that counts. Sure, the Mandos were an annoying group of authorial pets, but compared to the ending of the series and the mess Invincible left things in I think the glorification of Mandos is not a big deal. Jacen's death and the flop ending are.
In my opinion, the first RC book was pretty ok.
It's ok though! He thought the RC books were pretty OK.
Post any more you find here.